Photo Courtesy of The Dolphin Project
The Detrimental Effects of Captivity on Orcas
Captivity has devastating effects on orcas, or killer whales, profoundly impacting their physical and psychological well-being. In the wild, orcas are apex predators that roam vast distances, swimming up to 100 miles a day and diving to depths of over 300 feet. They live in complex social structures, often staying with their family pods for life, and communicate through a range of vocalizations unique to each pod.
In stark contrast, captivity confines orcas to tanks that are mere fractions of the size of their natural range. The limited space and artificial conditions lead to numerous health problems, including the collapse of the dorsal fin, which affects over 90% of captive orcas but is rare in the wild. Captive orcas also suffer from dental issues, ulcers, and a significantly reduced life expectancy. Psychologically, the stress of captivity causes orcas to exhibit abnormal behaviors, such as aggression towards humans and other orcas, repetitive swimming patterns, and even self-harm. The lack of mental stimulation and forced interaction with humans in performance settings exacerbate these issues, making captivity an inhumane environment for these highly intelligent creatures.
Protections for Southern Resident Orcas in Washington State
In Washington State, the Southern Resident orcas, a unique and endangered population, have garnered specific legal protections due to the numerous threats they face, such as the decline of their primary prey, Chinook salmon, vessel noise, and environmental pollutants. To address these threats, Washington State has implemented several important regulations and initiatives.
Governor Jay Inslee established the Southern Resident Orca Task Force in 2018, which was tasked with developing a comprehensive recovery plan for these orcas. The task force made over 40 recommendations, many of which have been implemented through state legislation. One key regulation is the Vessel Distance Law (RCW 77.15.740), which requires vessels to stay at least 300 yards away from Southern Resident orcas and maintain a slow speed zone of 400 yards to reduce noise pollution and disturbance. This law also mandates that vessels slow down within 1,000 yards of orcas, helping to minimize the underwater noise that interferes with their echolocation.
Washington State has also invested heavily in Chinook salmon recovery programs, including habitat restoration projects, dam removals, and hatchery programs. These efforts are crucial, as the decline in Chinook salmon is a primary factor in the endangerment of the Southern Resident orcas. Additionally, the state has taken steps to reduce the levels of toxic chemicals in the waters where these orcas forage, with the Department of Ecology working to decrease pollutants like PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) that accumulate in the orcas’ prey and harm their health.
U.S. Regulations on Capturing Orcas
At the federal level, the United States has enacted several robust laws to protect orcas and other marine mammals from being captured and kept in captivity. The Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA) of 1972 is the cornerstone of marine mammal conservation in the U.S. It prohibits the "take" of marine mammals in U.S. waters and by U.S. citizens on the high seas, where "take" is defined as harassing, hunting, capturing, or killing. The MMPA includes provisions for permits for scientific research, public display, or species enhancement, but these are strictly regulated. Since the 1990s, no new permits have been issued for the capture of orcas in U.S. waters for public display.
Additionally, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973 provides further protections for orcas, particularly the Southern Resident population, which is listed as endangered under the ESA. Under this law, it is illegal to "take" endangered species, which includes activities that would harass, harm, or capture them. The ESA also requires federal agencies to ensure that their actions do not jeopardize the continued existence of endangered species or destroy their critical habitats.
The Animal Welfare Act (AWA) sets minimum standards for the care of marine mammals in captivity, including orcas, covering aspects such as tank size, water quality, and veterinary care. However, many animal rights advocates argue that the AWA’s standards are outdated and insufficient to meet the complex needs of orcas.
Global Regulations on Capturing Orcas
Worldwide, the regulation of orca capture varies significantly. Some nations have implemented strict bans, while others still permit the practice under certain conditions. The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) regulates the international trade of endangered species, including orcas. Orcas are listed under Appendix II, meaning their trade is allowed but strictly controlled through a system of permits. Capturing orcas for export to other countries requires CITES permits, which are only granted if it does not harm the survival of the species in the wild.
The International Whaling Commission (IWC), although primarily focused on whaling, has adopted measures that protect certain populations of orcas. However, the IWC does not have a comprehensive mandate over all aspects of orca capture and captivity.
Countries Allowing or Banning Orca Capture
Despite growing global awareness of the ethical concerns surrounding orca captivity, a few countries continue to allow the capture of orcas. Russia is currently the only country where orcas are still captured from the wild for sale to marine parks and aquariums, primarily in China. The capture of orcas in Russian waters, particularly from the Sea of Okhotsk, has been a significant source of supply for the global marine entertainment industry.
Conversely, several countries have banned the capture of orcas. The United States has effectively banned orca capture under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, with no new captures since the early 1990s. Canada made significant progress with the passage of Bill S-203, also known as the “Ending the Captivity of Whales and Dolphins Act,” in 2019. This law prohibits the capture, breeding, and keeping of cetaceans (including orcas) for entertainment purposes, with exceptions for rescues, rehabilitation, and research. The United Kingdom has banned the capture and keeping of orcas in captivity since the late 1980s, and no orcas have been held in UK facilities since 1991. Brazil also has strong protections in place, banning the capture and keeping of orcas and other cetaceans for commercial purposes.
Countries with Orcas in Captivity
Despite these bans, several countries still hold orcas in captivity, largely due to historical captures or the lack of legislation mandating their release. In the United States, approximately 20 orcas remain in captivity, primarily in SeaWorld parks in California, Florida, and Texas. SeaWorld’s announcement in 2016 to end its orca breeding program marked a significant step, but the existing orcas remain confined.
Russia holds several orcas in captivity, many of which were captured from the wild in recent years. China has seen a rapid expansion of marine parks, many of which house orcas imported from Russia, with an estimated 20 orcas currently held in Chinese facilities. Japan also has several captive orcas, including those at the Taiji Whale Museum and Kamogawa Sea World. In Spain, Loro Parque holds several orcas, which have been the subject of international controversy, particularly after incidents of aggression and the death of a trainer.
Legislation Needed to Protect Orcas in the U.S.
To further protect orcas in the United States, several pieces of legislation have been proposed or could be expanded. The ORCA Act (Orca Responsibility and Care Advancement Act) is a proposed federal law that would prohibit the breeding, wild capture, and interstate transportation of orcas for public display. This act is designed to phase out orca captivity in the U.S. by ensuring that the current generation of captive orcas is the last.
Strengthening the Marine Mammal Protection Act by enhancing penalties for violations, closing loopholes that allow the importation of captive-bred orcas, and providing greater resources for enforcement could further protect orcas from being captured or bred in captivity. Additionally, banning the importation and exportation of orcas and other cetaceans for public display purposes would prevent U.S. facilities from acquiring new orcas from countries that still allow captures.
Another critical step is to end captive breeding programs nationwide, following the lead of California’s Orca Protection and Safety Act (2016), which banned orca breeding and the use of orcas in entertainment shows within the state (Although there are no theatrical orca shows in California, orcas may still be part of educational presentations.)
The Challenges and Successes of Reintroducing Captive Orcas to the Wild
Reintroducing captive orcas to the wild is a complex and challenging process, with only a few documented attempts. The most famous of these is the case of Keiko, the orca who starred in the movie *Free Willy*. After the film's release in 1993, a massive public campaign led to Keiko’s relocation from a small tank in Mexico to a sea pen in Iceland in 1998, where he underwent rehabilitation. Despite years of preparation, Keiko struggled to integrate with wild orcas and continued to seek out human contact. He was eventually released into the wild in 2002 but died a year later in Norway, likely due to pneumonia.
Releasing an orca from captivity requires a carefully planned process. This begins with rehabilitation, where captive orcas must regain their physical fitness and natural behaviors, including hunting and socializing with other orcas. This process can take years and requires a specialized environment, such as a sea pen that mimics their natural habitat. Once released, orcas need to be closely monitored to ensure they adapt to their new environment. In some cases, supplementary feeding may be necessary if the orca struggles to catch prey.
Finding a suitable release site is also crucial for a successful reintroduction. This site must have a stable food supply and a compatible orca population, which can be particularly challenging for orcas that have spent their entire lives in captivity and may not have the social skills or knowledge to integrate with wild pods.
Global Efforts to Protect and Release Captive Orcas
Several organizations and initiatives are working tirelessly to protect orcas from captivity and facilitate the release of those currently in captivity. The Whale Sanctuary Project is at the forefront of these efforts, developing a coastal sanctuary in Nova Scotia, Canada, designed to provide a naturalistic environment for orcas and belugas retired from captivity. The sanctuary aims to offer these cetaceans a larger, more natural space while still receiving care and monitoring.
Ric O’Barry’s Dolphin Project, known for its work in ending dolphin captivity, also advocates for the release of captive orcas. They have been involved in numerous campaigns to close down marine parks and relocate cetaceans to sanctuaries. The Sea Shepherd Conservation Society is another key player in the fight against orca captivity, engaging in direct action campaigns against the capture of orcas in places like Russia and Japan. The Free Morgan Foundation is dedicated to the case of Morgan, a wild orca captured in the Netherlands and now held at Loro Parque in Spain, advocating for her release into a sea pen or a suitable wild habitat.
How Individuals Can Help the Cause
Ending orca captivity requires collective action, and individuals can contribute in several ways. Supporting legislation that protects orcas, such as the ORCA Act, by contacting local and federal representatives is crucial. Raising awareness about the realities of orca captivity through social media, public speaking, or community events can help shift public opinion and reduce the demand for marine parks.
Donating to or volunteering with advocacy organizations like The Whale Sanctuary Project, Dolphin Project, or Sea Shepherd is another impactful way to support the cause. Additionally, boycotting marine parks that keep orcas in captivity and encouraging others to do the same sends a strong message to the industry that there is no place for orca entertainment in the modern world.
Recent Strides Toward Ending Orca Captivity
In recent years, significant strides have been made towards ending orca captivity. One of the biggest breakthroughs was SeaWorld’s 2016 decision to end its orca breeding program and phase out theatrical orca shows, following years of pressure from activists and public backlash after the release of the documentary *Blackfish* in 2013. California’s Orca Protection and Safety Act, also passed in 2016, banned orca breeding and the use of orcas in entertainment shows within the state, setting a precedent for other states.
Canada’s Bill S-203, also known as the "Free Willy Bill," was a groundbreaking step towards ending cetacean captivity worldwide when it passed in 2019. The legislation made it illegal to keep or breed cetaceans for entertainment purposes in Canada, with only a few exceptions for rescue and rehabilitation.
Conclusion
While the fight to end orca captivity has seen considerable progress, the journey is far from over. Continued advocacy, education, and legislative action are essential to ensure that orcas are no longer subjected to the confines of captivity. By supporting efforts to build sanctuaries, pass protective laws, and raise awareness, there is hope that one day all orcas will be free to live out their lives in the vast, open oceans where they belong.
Comments